Listening to Andrea (Lunatica) sing this for years now, it's difficult to say whether I like this more. Amanda's voice is more powerful, but I feel Andrea had more emotion, especially on the last "help me." Amanda croons off into the guitar solo, while Andrea almost screams it. Since Sascha Paeth wrote the song (and therefore owns the copyright to it, not Lunatica), the musicality has no change between versions either -- same instrumentation, same time signature. Just different vocal timbres. This will have to grow on me.