Aggiungi un commento. Accedi a o registrati (è gratuito).
  • quentin_L4

    suaveslav gave a new dimension to this song.

    Luglio 2014

    The only thing about this song that makes me feel unhappy/sad is realizing that Trent has lost his touch. I am disappoint >:(

    Gennaio 2014
  • Spectre08

    psychopatej, because you want to listen to this over and over again

    Ottobre 2013
  • psychopatej

    how can I still not killing myself while listening to this

    Agosto 2013
  • BynVacum

    Too short... <3

    Aprile 2013
  • StreamHeaven

    Beautiful sad song...

    Settembre 2012
  • Blessedheart

    Trent don't give a shit if his piano ain't in tune.

    Agosto 2012
  • HAXER1993

    This song makes you feel unhappy for no reason. its so hauntingly brilliant

    Agosto 2011
  • tomthe74

    that slightly out-of-tune piano... beautiful.

    Agosto 2011
  • Sentenza1

    yay,my favorite...

    Maggio 2011
  • Kimberly-Jade


    Maggio 2011
  • anna_creep

    my favorite

    Gennaio 2011
  • suaveslav

    Damn it, this really is turning into a livejournal post. Very serendipitous, it's been a year since I listened to this song (same time as my last comment), and I just realized the emotional connection between these two moments: when I listened to it at the end of last November I was finishing a half-year studying in Beijing and literally a week and several Chinese exams away from coming home to the US. Now I'm back at college in the US and two days away from returning home for the first time in three months, and I have to finish the second half of a eight-to-ten-page paper and make some finishing touches to my Chinese thesis. Oh, and the song's still as touching as ever.

    Novembre 2010
  • suaveslav

    IndustryRocker basically said what I wanted to about half a year before I did. Maybe I should be writing this in a livejournal post, but this song is beautifully damaged, the ever-so-slightly out-of-tune piano adding indescribable emotion.

    Novembre 2009
  • johndoe7474

    my fave off ghosts

    Luglio 2009
  • IndustryRocker

    The out-of-tune piano give this song a sort of strange feeling. It feels like the whole world is decaying below my feet.

    Giugno 2009
  • whiteheron


    Maggio 2009
  • alvareo

    I love how some pianos in Ghosts are out of tune.

    Aprile 2009
  • jamierobertward

    What does it matter? Each produces the same off-key effect.

    Marzo 2009
  • Bezzly

    Actually never mind, i think it's just out of tune :P

    Febbraio 2009
  • Bezzly

    I'm really curious to know if the piano in this track is simply out of tune, or if it has been tuned to a scale western ears aren't used to..

    Febbraio 2009
  • Salzella

    the cricket noise sounded like it was coming from behind me, it scared me :(

    Gennaio 2009
  • Pogofied

    fuggin gorgeous. <333333333333333333333333333

    Novembre 2008
  • plonka3000

    i love this song... one of the best off ghosts.

    Luglio 2008
  • Joshoewaa

    its hard to notice the cricket without headphones on... great.. ending on a slow, more mellow notes.

    Giugno 2008
  • Noise_Boy

    This track flows onto the cover of Dead Souls really well.

    Aprile 2008
  • damik

    Yeah, of course the out-of-tune piano is intentional. I think it improves the track anyway. Funny, I never noticed the cricket on the track before now.

    Aprile 2008
  • miss_maleficus

    I think it's intended to be lo-fi, but that damn cricket is annoying!

    Aprile 2008
  • RDM3000

    One of the best.

    Aprile 2008
  • Majsz

    so sad

    Aprile 2008
  • Knifymoloko

    Just listening to the song brings me closure... from what you ask? I'm not sure exactly.

    Marzo 2008
  • LuckyMark81

    heartbreakingly beautiful

    Marzo 2008
  • varaciel

    Fav track.

    Marzo 2008
  • OneSalient should have all the Ghosts tracks available as free mp3 downloads. Permission from NIN is not needed since the music has been licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Share Alike license. I was able to download the entire album (36 tracks) in both .mp3 and .flac formats at a bitorrent site. This was not illegal as the CC license allows it.

    Marzo 2008
  • silentinfinite

    Apparently I'm not the only one bothered by that sound. Kept removing my headphones. Pretty annoying :( Otherwise, this track is perfect.

    Marzo 2008
  • Knifymoloko

    @Detr!tus same for me too! Pretty crazy how the sound sounds 'real', like its right by you...

    Marzo 2008
  • Detr!tus

    @crono333 Same for me, I kept glancing over my shoulder, hehe

    Marzo 2008
  • isolationtheory

    I wonder if the clipping and distortion going on here and on many other piano/mallet things thoughout the album was intentional..

    Marzo 2008
  • crono333

    woah... listening to this track with headphones, there is a repeating 'cricket-type sound' on the right channel that sounded like it was coming from outside my window. I was totally convinced it was real until I removed the headphones...

    Marzo 2008
  • chochos

    great ending to the whole thing. There's never gonna be a better ending than Leaving Hope, but this is right up there.

    Marzo 2008
  • AfektAct


    Marzo 2008
  • Katie_Anne

    Ghosts I-IV kicks ass =)

    Marzo 2008
  • void__

    would make a great intro into a song, not sure which song yet though lol kinda like they use the fragile before certain songs etc.

    Marzo 2008
  • SSX19

    Love it. So fucking dramatic.

    Marzo 2008
  • IndefiniteCure

    why so detuned?

    Marzo 2008
  • KilgoreTrout2

    cool closer

    Marzo 2008